Looking for the best matchmaker services of 2025? You’ve come to the right place! With dating apps losing their appeal and more singles facing dating burnout, it’s no wonder why matchmaking is making a major comeback. In 2025 alone, the matchmaking industry is expected to grow by over 5%, while dating apps are looking at a sharp decline.
Singles are waking up to the fact that finding love isn’t a numbers game. They’re realizing that real relationships can’t be made through artificial algorithms. And they’re looking towards professional matchmakers who genuinely care about their journey to help guide them to a loving, lasting partnership.
But with literally hundreds of matchmaking services across the US, it can be a real challenge to find the best firm for you. Not all matchmakers are created equally, and some make bigger promises than they can deliver.
At LUMA, we believe that choosing a matchmaker should be exciting and empowering, not overwhelming. That’s why we’ve compiled all the latest reviews on the top matchmaking services in the US to help you find the matchmaker who aligns best with your values and goals. After all, having been established for over two decades, we know a thing or two about the best matchmaker services.
We will break down what to look for in a matchmaking service and how the top companies compare. No matter if you’re looking for high-end, VIP options or for something more affordable, we’ll help you cut through the noise and find the top matchmaking services that’s right for you.
What Makes the Best Matchmaker Services Stand Out in 2025?
With so many matchmakers all promising to help you find real, lasting love, it can be difficult to know what truly sets the best matchmaker services apart. Here’s the truth: great matchmakers don’t just make big promises. They provide a clear, personalized path to helping you find amazing matches.
Any good matchmaker will prioritize quality over quantity, vet every potential match for compatibility, and be your support system throughout your dating journey. The most reputable firms have a low matchmaker-to-client ratio, ensuring you receive dedicated, personalized guidance every step of the way.
So, what exactly should you be looking for? Here are the qualities that set top matchmaking services apart:
- Bespoke Matching, No Algorithms Involved
You should never feel like just another profile or data point to your matchmaker. The best matchmaker takes the time to truly understand your story, values, lifestyle, and long-term goals to match you with someone who compliments your life. And of course, matchmakers hand-select the best possible candidates, no apps or algorithms involved!
- Thorough Match Vetting
Any reputable matchmaker will screen all potential matches to ensure they are who they say they are. With catfishing and date scamming so common in the dating scene, a matchmaker can help take the guesswork out of verifying your date’s information. Plus, matchmakers only introduce you to the most compatible matches, making bad first dates few and far between.
- Confidentiality and Discretion
Privacy is one of the biggest concerns for singles, and rightfully so! Unfortunately, dating apps fail to keep your personal information safe, making them completely unviable for anyone looking to keep their search for love under wraps. The top matchmaking services protect your private information and only make introductions on a first-name basis.
- Post-Date Feedback and Support
The best matchmaker services offer so much more than introductions. Most high-end matchmakers provide relationship coaching and post-date feedback to help you put your best foot forward with your matches. They’ll guide you on everything from first impressions, conversation topics, and how to build a lasting relationship. These are all assets that dating apps fail to offer.
The Top Matchmaking Services Compared
Every matchmaker is different. From their matchmaking approach, level of support, and inclusion of concierge-level add ons like date planning, each firm has their pros and cons. Whether you’re looking for a luxury, high-touch experience or something more standardized and hands-off, it’s crucial to understand each firm’s model and how they can help you find love.
We’ve broken down six of the best matchmaker services in 2025 to help you decide which one is best aligned with your preferences and relationship goals.
Tawkify
Scalable & Accessible, But Mixed Client Reviews
Tawkify positions itself as an affordable and accessible matchmaking firm for singles across the US. Founded in 2012 by Elle advice columnist E. Jean Carroll and tech entrepreneur Kenneth Shaw, Tawkify is now considered to be one of the leading firms in the nation.
Their process is similar to most other firms; an onboarding consultation, access to a dedicated matchmaker, personality assessments, and date planning with the matches they select for you. They also conduct follow-up sessions after each date and offer coaching options for an additional cost.
Tawkify has also been the defendant for two lawsuits to date. In 2021, Jeremy Stanfield filed a lawsuit against Tawkify to challenge the validity of their arbitration agreement outlined in their terms of service. Tawkify’s other verifiable lawsuit, Larue vs. Tawkify, accuses Tawkify of victimizing workers and not paying fair, competitive wages to its employees. However, the case was recently dismissed by the residing Florida Federal judge.
According to Tawkify’s reviews, their past clients have mixed emotions. Some appreciate how easy the process is and say their matchmakers were deeply supportive, while other clients have left feeling less than happy, calling Tawkify a “total and complete waste of money”. Their reviews across Reddit, Sitejabber, BBB, and Glassdoor leave us concerned about the quality of matches, legal complaints, and lawsuits the company has faced.
Tawkify Pros and Cons at a Glance:
- Packages start around $4,900, with pricing based on the number of matches selected
- Tends to work best for singles looking for affordability and broad match searches
- 115 BBB complaints filed over the past 3 years
- Not ideal for singles expecting luxury, high-touch experiences
- Trustpilot reviews are largely positive, but other platforms tell a different story
Kelleher International
A Legacy Brand with a Complicated Reputation
Kelleher International is one of the most recognized names in the matchmaking industry. Founded in 1986 by Jill Kelleher and later joined by her daughter Amber Kelleher-Andrews, Kelleher caters to high-net-worth singles seeking exclusive matches in the U.S. and internationally. Uniquely, their model pairs clients with a small team of matchmakers and promises premium, hands-on service.
That said, Kelleher’s reputation has been stained by serious complaints and controversies. A 2017 lawsuit from former QVC executive Darlene Daggett revealed concerning issues about the way they screen matches. Daggett alleged that her “elite” matches included married men, felons, and even people with professional sanctions. Another unresolved allegation from 2009 involves a traumatic assault incident, raising questions about Kelleher’s commitment to client safety and match screening process.
I’m sure you’re wondering about Kelleher’s reviews. While some client testimonials on Kelleher’s website are positive, third-party reviews are few and far between. Most trustworthy platforms (like Trustpilot and Reddit) show no reviews at all for Kelleher, and the reviews we can see question Kelleher’s match quality and pricing transparency.
Kelleher Pros and Cons at a Glance:
- Pricing ranges from $30,000 to $300,000+ depending on the match search radius
- Contracts range from one to three years
- Claims 89% success rate but provides no data to but it up
- Very limited public reviews on trusted platforms
- Best for singles with large budgets who are unfazed by lawsuits
Ambiance Matchmaking
Artistic, Conscious, and Controversial Spin
Ambiance Matchmaking caters to “conscious creatives, entrepreneurs, and thought leaders,” through a boutique service focused on personal and spiritual growth. Co-founded by Leslie Wardman and Taylor Wade, the company currently serves 11 US cities. Wardman, the current CEO, claims to have lived in each city they serve to better understand local dating culture.
The matchmaking process includes a $225 in-person consultation fee that’s credited toward membership if you’re accepted, one to two curated matches per month, and feedback after each date. VIP clients can access private photo previews of their matches, despite this being against traditional industry standards as it breaches confidentiality.
To date, Ambiance has been the defendant in one public lawsuit. A previous client, Jane Woods, took Ambiance to small claims court for allegedly breaching the terms of her contract. According to Woods, she was promised one to two matches per month as outlined in the terms of her membership. We are able to corroborate that claim as Ambiance clearly lists this on their website. Unfortunately, we cannot find any information on the outcome of the case.
Ambience reviews are mixed overall. Although Ambiance certainly lists glowing testimonials on their website, reviews across Google, Yelp, Reddit, and Bonjour Matchmaking (a competitor) tell a different story. Most complaints generally talk about the lack of communication with their matchmaker and feeling dissatisfied with their matches.
Ambiance Pros and Cons at a Glance:
- Pricing ranges from $25,000 to $100,000 depending on the match search radius
- Offers personalized support and guidance, but lack verifiable results
- Some clients report poor communication and mismatched expectations
- Best for clients drawn to spiritual or personal growth-oriented matchmaking
VIDA Select
A Tech-Driven Matchmaking Hybrid
VIDA Select is a hybrid model that combines traditional, hands-on matchmaking with digital dating tools. Unlike most other firms, VIDA Select doesn’t rely on in-house matchmakers; their firm uses algorithms, online dating profiles, and client-managed dating apps to find matches. They even message potential partners on your behalf before handing the conversation off to you.
Their subscription-style model is structured around monthly packages and offers dating app profile optimization, photo editing, and ongoing match sourcing from their internal database and other dating apps. Their model is a good fit for tech savvy singles who are still interested in using online dating platforms to find love.
That said, VIDA Select has been scrutinized for their lack of transparency. They claim a 99% date rate and 82% relationship rate, but they don’t show any methodology or data sources on their website. As far as VIDA Select’s reviews go, it’s another mixed bag. Trustpilot has hundreds of positive reviews, but their BBB profile has a 2.67 out of 5-star rating.
Although VIDA Select doesn’t have any public lawsuits, they do have 8 total complaints in the last 3 years. Most complaints discuss issues with match quality or not receiving any matches at all, and matchmakers having poor communication skills.
VIDA Select Pros and Cons at a Glance:
- Pricing starts at $1,195/month and goes up to $2,595/month
- Clients pay for the matchmaker’s time, not a set number of matches
- Good for professionals who are still open to dating app use
- Lacks exclusivity, luxury, and personalization
- Best for tech-savvy clients on a budget
Exclusive Matchmaking
Investigative Matchmaking With A Narrow Focus
Exclusive Matchmaking was founded by Susan Trombetti, a former private investigator who made the transition into matchmaking. Given Trombetti’s background, it makes sense why Exclusive Matchmaking has a strong emphasis on client background checks, selective membership, and dating coaching. Their firm positions as a concierge-style service for wealthy, relationship-minded men.
Trombetti’s approach is personalized, including one-on-one coaching, feedback sessions, and private “Bachelor Parties” where potential matches are introduced at upscale venues. To any ladies interested in Exclusive Matchmaking, please be aware that their paid matchmaking packages are men-only. However, Trombetti does have coaching programs tailored toward women.
If you’re searching for Exclusive Matchmaking reviews, you might be disappointed; the firm has very few third-party reviews. With only three reviews total across Google, Indeed, and BBB, it’s nearly impossible to know what their clients truly felt about their memberships. That said, Exclusive Matchmaking has no recorded lawsuits or formal complaints, which is a good sign.
Key considerations:
- Consultation fees start between $350–$550; full matchmaking ranges from $7,500 to $250,000+
- Lack of reviews makes it difficult to see how their clients felt about their membership
- Best for high-net-worth men looking for a hands-on approach
- Unique services like “Investigate Your Date” set it apart, but with limited transparency
How LUMA Compares to Other Top Matchmaking Services
Hand-Selected Introductions, No Algorithms Involved
While some matchmakers use an algorithm-heavy, technology and automation-focused model, LUMA believes that real human intuition is unmatched when it comes to love. Chemistry, compatibility, and relationships aren’t something an algorithm can truly measure. At LUMA, every client is paired with a dedicated, certified matchmaker who takes the time to understand them on a personal level. From the beginning, our focus is on building connection through compatibility, not apps.
Quality Over Quantity
Many of the top matchmaking services play a numbers game when it comes to love. Their model is based on a pay-for-matches system that encourages mass introductions over deep, meaningful connections. At LUMA, we believe the opposite: our model is based on quality over quantity, ensuring you are only introduced to the highest caliber, most desirable singles. Our matchmakers interview 50+ candidates per client, carefully vetting each potential match to ensure they’re truly compatible with your lifestyle and ambitions.
Personalized Support And Guidance
Some of the best matchmaker services might stop at the introduction, but LUMA offers personalized support and guidance every step of the way. We’re more than just a matchmaking service: we’re your sounding board and mentor throughout your journey. From date planning, wardrobe consultations, and date and relationship coaching, we’re committed to helping our clients elevate their life holistically. All of our matchmakers are also Certified Life Coaches, ensuring that each client receives the feedback and guidance to help them put their best foot forward in their dating life.
A Trusted Reputation
The matchmaking industry is unfortunately rife with lawsuits, client disputes, and overwhelmingly negative reviews. At LUMA, our reputation as a trusted firm has been earned through our integrity. Our strict vetting process ensures that we only work with clients we believe we can genuinely help, and we maintain the highest standards of discretion and professionalism. And of course, our match screening process is just as rigorous. Our commitment to safety, privacy, and transparency is what sets us apart.
Inclusive, Nationwide, & Boutique
Many of the top matchmaking services only specialize in one region or type of client. LUMA has matchmakers in every corner of the nation, ensuring we can help you no matter if you’re in Dallas, New York City, or a small, rural area. Each of our matchmakers specialize in a unique demographic, making our client based diverse and rich. We have matchmakers who specialize in LBGTQ matchmaking, Muslim matchmaking, and even Celebrity matchmaking. Unlike most other nationwide firms, LUMA is still founder owned and operated, making our service deeply personal and boutique.
Concierge-Style Service
Unlike some of the best matchmaker services, LUMA treats each client to an upscale, elevated dating experience. From the moment you begin your journey with us, your service is entirely personalized and hands-on. Our matchmakers coordinate every first date, provide feedback after every introduction, and truly invest in your success. Our VIP members enjoy additional benefits such as professional photoshoots, personal image consulting, health and wellness coaching, and even exclusive events.
Which Matchmaking Service Is Right For You?
Choosing the best matchmaker for you entirely depends on your relationship goals, membership expectations, and budget. Some matchmakers provide a broader, more automated service, while others are niche, high-touch, and focused on specific regions or demographics. Ultimately, the best choice depends on what you need to feel supported, seen, and successful.
Before committing to any matchmaking service, take the time to really consider what you’re looking for. Do you need a coach and accountability partner, or are introductions enough? Do you value exclusivity, luxury, and deep vetting, or are you looking for something less encompassing? How important is privacy, coaching, success metrics, and inclusivity?
Of course, you’ll also need to do a deeper dive on each matchmaker’s reviews. Look beyond their website for real, third-party platform reviews and success claims. Determine what their previous clients have said to see what kind of support you’ll receive, how matches are selected, and the quality of the matches you’ll receive.
Why LUMA May Be The Right Fit For You
If you’re ready to invest in your love life and are seeking a deeply intentional, supportive, and human-first approach, LUMA may be the best fit for you.
Our process is entirely curated, hands-on, and led through care, connection, and expert guidance. That’s why our matchmakers look beyond surface-level compatibility and invest the time to truly understand who you are and what you’re truly looking for. We offer personalized coaching, meaningful introductions, and tailored feedback at every step of your journey.
And of course, our service focused on building real relationships, so there’s no apps or algorithms involved. Our process is entirely confidential, highly selective, and personalized to your needs, preferences, and relationship goals. If you’re ready to start investing in a process that’s designed for you, we’re ready to be your guide.
Complete your profile and schedule a private consultation with one of our certified matchmakers today.
