Matchmakers vs. Dating Apps: Pros and Cons You should Know

When the coronavirus started to spread internationally early in 2020, many predicted that dating app usage would go down. They were mistaken; that wasn’t what happened. In fact, popular dating apps Tinder, Bumble, and OkCupid all saw a surge in activity during the pandemic.

Together with online dating services, matchmaking services also saw an uptick in business during the pandemic. Some matchmakers in San Diego report having more clients now than before COVID-19 struck.

The activity surge is understandable given that many singles are struggling with loneliness and are touch-starved due to having to shelter at home and maintain their social distance with one another. Since they can no longer date the way they used to, it’s unsurprising that people would turn to dating apps and matchmaking services to make human connections.

If you’re also looking for a way to reenter the dating scene cautiously, online dating and matchmaking are good options to consider. Here’s a comparison of their pros and cons to help you pick the most suitable one for your preferences.

Dating Apps

Convenience and ease of use are the biggest advantages of dating apps. It doesn’t hurt that they’re free, too. If you want premium features, such as advanced filters and the ability to extend time on your matches, you only need to pay a small monthly subscription fee.


  • There’s no pressure. With dating apps, you can keep everything as casual as you want. There’s no pressure to commit to something long-term, unlike with matchmaking services where people are more likely to be looking for something serious. If you’re not looking for a lifetime partner, you can find plenty of users on dating apps who are on the same page as you.
  • They’re great for practice. If you’ve been out of the dating scene for a while, apps like Tinder and Bumble are great ways to get back into the swing of things. You can use these platforms to practice talking and flirting with people. These apps also help you determine what your dating non-negotiables are.


  • Catfishing is a risk. Many dating app profiles are fake, and some studies warn against the increasing number of catfishers amid the pandemic. It can be easy to be duped by these frauds, so even if you’re having fun, you still need to be vigilant when talking to people on the app.
  • Swiper’s fatigue is real. Recent studies show that scrolling and swiping can make users feel lonely for various reasons. Being ghosted, not making enough matches, and not finding someone you connect with can all take a toll on your mental and emotional health.

Matchmaking Services

The top advantage of using a matchmaking service is higher chance of being matched with someone compatible. Matchmakers ask you exactly what you want in a partner and connect you with someone who fits the bill, increasing the chances of a successful match. So, if you don’t want to exhaust yourself with trial-and-error dates, a matchmaking service is for you.


  • Matchmakers ensure your privacy. Dating app profiles are public; users can use your information to look for your other social media accounts. Meanwhile, matchmakers guarantee total privacy. They’ll also confirm your interest before they send out your information to potential matches.
  • You’ll go on organized dates. Matchmakers don’t just set you up with someone; they’ll also arrange dates for you. They take out the stress of planning a date and the fear that the other person might not like your choice. Your matchmaker will organize a day or night out that both parties will enjoy. If your location still has strict COVID-19 safety regulations, the matchmaker will also make sure to take those into account when planning the activity.


  • Matchmakers can be pricey. Depending on who you’re working with, matchmaking services can range from $500 to $25,000. The good news is that most matchmakers offer customizable packages to fit their clients’ needs and preferences.
  • Some matchmakers are inexperienced. Those who are new to the industry might underdeliver and give you incompatible matches. So make sure to hire a trusted, experienced matchmaker to get your money’s worth.

Dating Apps vs. Matchmaking Services

The choice depends on what you’re looking for. If you want something casual, dating apps are the way to go. These will give you the flexibility you want as there is no pressure to make a commitment when you’re not ready.

If you’re ready for something serious, however, don’t waste your time on dating apps. Matchmaking services can make the search easier and faster for you. They’ll help you find a highly compatible match in a safe and secure way.

Luxury Matchmaker in Chicago

LUMA Luxury Matchmaking, a renowned Chicago matchmaker, provides premium services to those who are looking for “The One.” We offer a unique and personalized matchmaking experience that takes out the stress and anxiety of dating.

Contact us today to learn more about our matchmaking services.

Make Sure You Take The Next Steps To Meet Your Match!

Join our Network if you haven’t already and then Meet with a Matchmaker!
0 Points

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *