Finding the right matchmaking service can feel just as daunting as dating itself. According to IBIS World, the dating services industry grew by over 1% in 2024 alone, showing just how in demand high-end dating services are becoming. With thousands of companies promising elite introductions or guarantees on love, it can be exhausting to separate the true dating experts from the marketing-savvy scammers.
At LUMA, we’ve seen firsthand just how impactful great matchmaking can be, and how disappointing it is when services overpromise and underdeliver. That’s why we created this guide. We’ve outlined the top rated matchmaking services based on their real client reviews, success metrics, and pricing structure.
We’ve included some of the best matchmaking services in the US, from small, boutique firms to national, large-scale companies. Here’s everything you need to know before investing your time, energy, and heart into any service.
1. The Matchmaking Company: Nationwide Firm With Mixed Reviews
The Matchmaking Company is one of the most recognizable names in the industry, with over 40 affiliate branches across the US. This firm positions itself as a luxury dating service for serious singles, but its reputation raises some question. Some clients appreciate the structure and local support networks, but others say the firm doesn’t live up to it’s promises. Yet, it’s one of the most searched names for top rated matchmaking services.
How The Matchmaking Company Works
To get started, clients schedule an in-person consultation with a New Client Advisor at their closest branch. Their team will ask about your dating history, relationship goals, and preferences. Then, the team builds your profile and invites you to purchase a matchmaking package. You’re then matched by a team of matchmakers at that local branch.
Once you agree to meet a match, you receive your match’s contact information and are responsible for planning the date. After each date, you’ll be asked to give feedback.
Pricing
The Matchmaking Company doesn’t list their pricing structure on their website, but based on client reviews and complaints, pricing seems to range between $1,500 and $10,000. Pricing varies based on location and the level of service.
Pros
- In-person consultations and local support
- Structured, transparent process
- Branches spread across the US, making it accessible to most
Cons
- Does not plan dates
- No dedicated, one-on-one matchmaker
- Serious concerns about sales tactics and client reviews
Reputation
This is where The Matchmaking Company struggles. Some clients leave positive feedback about their matchmakers’ support, but many others address issues with unmet membership terms, unqualified matches, and lack of transparency. Below, we will list some of their third-party ratings. As they have over 40 affiliate branches, these reviews do vary by the branch location.
- Yelp: 1.2 stars
- Trustpilot: 3.8 stars
- Google: 3.5 stars
- Glassdoor: 4.6 stars
There are multiple public complaints, including accusations of bait-and switch sales tactics, reusing testimonials, and even a case about an elderly woman with dementia. The Matchmaking Company might be one of the largest firms in the industry, but its track record makes us question whether it’s truly one of the best matchmaking services.
2. Tawkify: Modern Matchmaking With A Tech-Forward System
Tawkify is one of the top rated matchmaking services in the US, in part because of their blended matchmaking method. Unlike more traditional matchmakers, Tawkify blends data and algorithms with their matchmaking intuition. Their model is built on efficiency, designed mainly for busy professionals who want a curated dating experience without stress.
How Tawkify Works
Tawkify’s process begins with a short phone consultation. Then, clients complete a detailed profile describing their values, relationship goals, and match preferences. Your assigned matchmaker will then select matches and plan dates on your behalf. You won’t see photos before meeting your matches in-person, as Tawkify upholds client confidentiality. After each date, both parties provide feedback to help fine tune future matches.
Pricing
Tawkify’s matchmaking packages generally range between $3,000 and $6,000, depending on location, length of membership, and number of guaranteed matches.
Pros
- More affordable than high-end, luxury firms
- Matchmakers handle all introductions and date planning
- Affordable and low-pressure process
Cons
- Matchmaker quality and experience can vary
- Less personalized than luxury firms
- No photo preview can be a dealbreaker for some
Reputation
Tawkify has been featured in major media outlets such as The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times. While some clients have found lasting relationships, other reviewers report inconsistent match quality and a lack of transparency. We will list some of Tawkify’s third-party ratings below.
- Yelp: 2.6 stars
- Trustpilot: 4.4 stars
- Better Business Bureau: 2.37 stars
- Glassdoor: 2.3 stars
Overall, Tawkify has garnered some mixed reviews. Still, it’s arguably is one of the best matchmaking services for singles looking for a hands-off, curated dating journey.
3. Kelleher: Legacy Firm With A Mixed Reputation
There’s no doubt that Kelleher International stands out as one of the top rated matchmaking services in the US. The firm is known for its personalized approach in connecting high-profile celebrities and professionals looking for real relationships. Having been established for over 30 years, Kelleher has built a reputation for exclusivity and discretion. However, the firm has also been the defendant in a few major, public lawsuits.
How Kelleher Works
Clients start with an in-depth interview process to understand their relationship goals, dating preferences, and lifestyle. A team of one to three matchmakers will then make introductions from their internal network of singles. Kelleher seems to emphasize quality over quantity and focus on real compatibility in their matchmaking process. Clients also attend regular feedback sessions to continually fine tune the process.
Pricing
Membership fees range from $30,000 to over $300,000, depending on the scope of the match search and the level of membership selected.
Pros
- Highly personalized matchmaking with a dedicated team
- Extensive network of elite, vetted singles
- Strong track record of successful matches
Cons
- Luxury pricing might be inaccessible for some
- Limited online client reviews due to confidentiality
- Multiple, high-profile lawsuits and serious allegations
Reputation
Kelleher might position itself as one of the best matchmaking services for high-income singles, but its reputation has been steeped in controversy. The company has faced multiple public complaints, lawsuits, and even disturbing allegations that have raised red flags across the industry. Below, we will list a few of their third-party ratings and lawsuits. However, keep in mind that most of their profiles on third-party review sites only have a few reviews.
- Yelp: 1 star
- Better Business Bureau: 1 star
- Reviews.io: 5 stars
- Glassdoor: 3.7 stars
Kelleher’s most troubling complaint was a case in 2009 that detailed a sexual assault and alleged cover-up involving a Kelleher client and their match.
Despite these serious allegations, Kelleher still remains one of the top rated matchmaking services because of their legacy and brand recognition. However, their complaints and lack of presence of major review platforms raises more questions and concerns.
4. Ambiance Matchmaking: Boutique Services For Professionals
Ambiance Matchmaking brands itself as one of the best matchmaking services in the nation. The firm caters to “conscious leaders, creatives, and entrepreneurs” seeking lasting relationships. Founded in 2002, the company specializes in personalized, boutique matchmaking, where the founder, Leslie Wardman, is personally involved with client experience.
How Ambiance Works
Before joining, prospective clients will undergo a thorough interview process to understand their relationships goals and preferences. Once accepted, members can expect one to two curated introductions per month. Ambiance will also arrange dates and gather post-date feedback to refine their matchmaking process.
Pricing
Ambiance does not publicly disclose a membership price range, but client reviews suggest packages range from $10,000 to $25,000. Fees seem to vary by the scope of search.
Pros
- Personalized, founder-led matchmaking
- Prioritizes client growth and relationship readiness
- Services most major US cities
Cons
- Lack of information on pricing and success metrics
- Mixed reviews across third-party platforms
- Not accredited by the Better Business Bureau
Reputation
Ambiance Matchmaking has a complicated online reputation. Some clients praise the personalized service and quality matches, but other address concerns about the value of their membership versus the cost.
In 2016, a client sued the company in small claims court over unmet membership expectations, further damaging their reputation. Below, we will list its reviews, but Ambiance has 27 locations across the US, so ratings for each location may vary.
Despite their mixed reviews and public lawsuit, Ambiance is still one of the top rated matchmaking services in the US, in part because of their exclusivity and growth-driven approach.
5. VIDA Select: Modern, Digital-Driven Matchmaking
VIDA Select stands out among the best matchmaking services in the US because of their unique method. The firms blends traditional matchmaking intuition with modern online dating techniques. Unlike other matchmakers, VIDA Select offers flexible, month-to-month memberships without long-term contracts, which caters toward singles trying matchmaking for the first time.
How VIDA Select Works
Clients begin with an in-depth interview to outline their relationship goals and dating preferences. VIDA’s team then creates online dating profiles and manages swiping, messaging, and arranging dates for their clients. Clients may also be introduced to VIDA’s internal network of pre-screened matches. The firm’s largely hands-off approach allows clients to use dating apps without the typical stress and hassle.
Pricing
VIDA Select offers three tiers of membership: Basic, starting at $1,195 per month, Premium, ranging from $1,795 to $2,395 per month, and Elite, starting at $2,595 per month.
Pros
- Pay-as-you-go model with no long-term contracts
- Tech-forward approach is appealing to some
- High success rate; 82% of clients find a relationship
Cons
- Mixed reviews about customer service
- Some clients complain about match quality
- Hands-off model may be unattractive to some
Reputation
VIDA Select has amassed a mixed reputation from multiple third-party online platforms. While many clients praise VIDA’s unique method and membership flexibility, others express dissatisfaction with their matches and unresponsiveness from their matchmaker. Below are the firm’s third party ratings.
- Trustpilot: 4.5 stars
- Better Business Bureau: 3 stars
- Glassdoor: 4.2 stars
Despite being unaccredited with the Better Business Bureau, VIDA Select has received 10 complaints on the site in the last 3 years. Still, the firm is widely recognized as one of the best matchmaking services in the US because of their transparency and flexible membership structure.
6. Exclusive Matchmaking: Elite Service For Discerning Singles
Exclusive Matchmaking positions itself as a high-end, personalized firm which caters to affluent men in the Northeastern US. The company emphasizes quality over quantity, dedicated client attention, and tailored matches. Exclusive Matchmaking’s founder, Susan Trombetti, is an acclaimed relationship and criminal investigation expert who still oversees the firm’s operations.
How Exclusive Matchmaking Works
The client application process starts with an extensive consultation. Unlike other firms, Exclusive Matchmaking charges between $350 and $550 for the initial consult, depending on whether it’s held virtually or in-person. During this session, the client’s relationship goals, preferences, and emotional availability will be assessed.
Once accepted, clients are paired with matches from the firm’s network. Exclusive Matchmaking also offers options like the “Bachelor Party”, a private event where clients meet potential matches, starting at $4,000.
Pricing
Exclusive Matchmaking’s membership options are premium-priced, ranging from $7,500 to over $250,000 depending on location, scope of search, and membership level.
Pros
- Highly personalized process tailored to client needs
- Unique add-ons like the “Bachelor Party” event
- No lawsuits or formal complaints
Cons
- Luxury pricing may not be affordable for some
- Caters to high-net-worth men, limited packages for women
- Few client testimonials and no public success metrics
Reputation
Exclusive Matchmaking has kept a low profile on third party review platforms, which makes it difficult to determine their real client satisfaction. However, their lack of legal issues and serious complaints do suggest the firm is successful. We will list Exclusive Matchmaking’s ratings below, but keep in mind that each platform only lists one review.
Although Exclusive Matchmaking only has three reviews on trusted third party platforms, it’s clean legal record and industry standing still make it one of the best matchmaking services in the US.
7. LUMA Luxury Matchmaking: Boutique, Bespoke International Matchmaking
Our firm, LUMA Luxury Matchmaking, is recognized as one of the top rated matchmaking services in the US. We offer a luxury dating experience deeply rooted in selectivity, discretion, and results. LUMA was built on the belief that meaningful relationships are built on deep compatibility, not surface-level attraction.
LUMA caters to celebrities, executives, entrepreneurs, and elite professionals who are serious about finding a long-term partner. Our highly specialized team serves all demographics, from Jewish singles to LGBTQ singles.
How LUMA Works
Our matchmakers at LUMA take a hands-on, deeply personal approach to matchmaking. To apply, prospective clients will complete their online LUMA profile and schedule an in-depth consultation with one of our certified matchmaker. After a membership offer has been extended, clients are paired with a dedicated matchmaker who conducts a private search through LUMA’s curated network of over 1,500,000 singles.
Unlike most firms that only use passive databases, our LUMA matchmakers actively recruit and screen matches for our clients. Each introduction is intentionally made based on shared values, client preferences, and relationship goals. LUMA matchmakers plan every date for their clients and offer post-date feedback sessions to refine the process. Coaching is ingrained in our method to ensure every client receives personal support throughout their dating journey.
Pricing
Our LUMA membership packages start at $15,000 and can range over $200,000 depending on the scope of the match search, location, and level of membership. We also have passive membership options available to singles who aren’t yet ready to invest in their love life.
Pros
- Highly personalized with one-on-one matchmaker support
- Extensive international reach and dedicated match recruiting
- Founder led and operated luxury, boutique service
Cons
- Premium packages may not be affordable for some
- Rigorous client acceptance process
- Passive members do not receive a dedicated match search
Reputation
LUMA is consistently recognized as one of the best matchmakers in the US for discerning singles seeking real, lasting relationships. LUMA’s founder, April Davis, has been featured in major media outlets such as Forbes, CBS, The New York Times, and The Real HouseWives of Orange County. We are acclaimed for our commitment to integrity and real client results. Below are our real client reviews on trusted, third party platforms.
- Better Business Bureau: 4.64 stars
- Yelp: 5 stars
- Google: 4.8 stars
- Glassdoor: 5 stars
Choosing The Best Matchmaker For You
The truth is that even among the top rated matchmaking services, not all firms provide the same level of care, personalization, or support. Some companies truly prioritize quality over quantity and a luxury experience, while others charge a luxury price without delivering compatible matches. That’s why it’s essential to dig into real client experiences, review platforms, and each company’s reputation before making a decision.
if you’re serious about finding a partner and ready to invest in a service that’s as intentional and elite as you are, it might be time to speak with our LUMA team. At LUMA, we don’t just match people; we build real, lasting relationships. Our selective, client-centered approach ensures you’re not just meeting anyone; you’re meeting the one.
